@geekryan:
1) But not reality warping, and most of those examples are outliers because Sue's force fields are not consistently universal +
At this point it's high-ends given the number of times it's happened and I'd personally say it's not because of the force fields' durability and it has more to do with their makeup and origin (being made of energy drawn from the same place Celestials come from)
2) We see Sue's force field shatter as the Cosmic Cube's energy passes through her, so it obviously did not last long at all, especially considering the use of the word "soon".
That panel just shows the point where her shields fell otherwise Reed would've said her force fields fell immediately
3) Again, that's not consistent for Sue. In this thread, you said yourself:
I meant she hasn't done it for that long before but she has made force fields she didn't concentrate on before but that can be because of growth as the current run puts a lot of emphasis on Sue's power growth and development and she's done plenty of stuff so far that's new or hasn't been explored yet
4) Until it can be replicated again and proven to be a consistent and new thing that Sue can do, it is PIS in my books.
That's fair as long as you apply this rule to every new feat of other characters
5) It's such a multi-faceted feat of Sue doing new stuff that I can't just take it at face value. If it was just Sue briefly blocking the reality warping effect, OR just Sue maintaining a force field on Reed without direct concentration, then I would be more willing to buy it. But all of these things happening at the same time, with all the factors in play? It's more PIS than not.
Fair enough
If this was done by Jean, or Magneto, or any other force field user who does not have magic/reality warping powers, my opinion on the matter would be the same.
But Sue's force fields are known to consistently do stuff no other force field can do given their nature and she shouldn't be limited to whatever other force fields can do
I know how you feel about Sue, and that nothing I say will change your mind about this, but I'm also not going to change my mind about this unless she gets more, similar feats like this. Only time will tell, so I'm not going to start saying Sue can block Cosmic Cube-level reality warping and maintain force fields without concentration just yet.
Again, I won't hold it against anyone who questions the credibility of the feat as long as they do the same with all other new feats that a character hasn't replicated before
Log in to comment